‘The Fifth Estate’ Review: Benedict Cumberbatch never gets a chance to shine
Part biography and part political thriller, The Fifth Estate brings Julian Assange and Wikileaks to the big screen in a film juiced with too much information for most viewers.
© 2013 DreamWorks II Distribution; LLC
Benedict Cumberbatch stars as Assange alongside his key supporter and “co-founder” Daniel Domscheit-Berg (Daniel Brühl) beginning with nothing and becoming the massive Wikileaks website, famous for leaking over 90,000 US military documents.
A whirlwind of camera shots during the creation of the website and “techy side” of investigative journalism becomes a more interesting political thriller puttiing Assange in the center of a moral dilemma.
The decision to release the thousands and thousands of US documents even though it may put lives in danger reveals a great moral challenge for the audience.
Sadly Benedict Cumberbatch never gets to stretch his acting chops with his portrayal of Assange. He captures the mannerisms and odd personality traits which have become evident in the press conference and speeches delivered by Assange over the years.
Brühl is very good as the central character driving the story, but there’s not enough meat to the script to warrant any special recognition. The same can be said for a great supporting cast, but the only real achievement on screen is the sneak peek at journalists’ battling the evolution of Internet news.
After two hours of a film suffering from an identity crisis, the audience final is spoon fed the meaning behind the film’s title and a concluding sequence of updates and Cumberbatch clips detailing what has transpired since 2010.
Overall the film is not a good fit for mass consumption, but should serve as a great conversation starter and educator for anyone who has missed the WikiLeaks phenomenon over the last five years.
Most fans will feel overwelmed by massive amounts of information with little reward at the end of their journey: 2 out of 5 stars.
If you are interested in news, working journalism or already know a lot about Julian Assange and Wikileaks: overall 3 out of 5 stars.
The Fifth Estate opens in theaters October 18, 2013.
FYI: Julian Assange has been vocal about his opposition to the representation in the film – read more from the WikiLeaks site here
[…] with Gregory Bernstein and Sara Bernstein to recount Gun as a heroic whistleblower, much like The Fifth Estate did for Julian Assange. Hood adds a great cast (Matt Smith, Matthew Goode, Adam Bakri, Indira […]
[…] Review: The Fifth Estate […]